Why Sony Reader and not the Amazon Kindle
December 25th, 2008 by eyal | No Comments | Filed in TechieI started writing this as a comment in response to Dave’s question and realized it was getting long enough to be a post so here it is:
There are quite a few devices out there in the market. The main ones are from: iRex, Hanlin, Bookeen, Sony and Amazon. Each has its advantages and disadvantages.
Almost all of the devices these days use the new generation Vizplex eInk screen, so their display is almost the same. I say almost because in some cases it isn’t, like with the new Sony PRS-700. Adding the touch screen capability has reportedly detracted from the crispness of the screen. Anyways, aside from the screen the differences are therefore in these areas:
- Formats supported - ideally one should match the source and format of their reading material with the ‘right’ kind of device that is able to display it in the best way.
- Price
- Build quality / looks
- Extra features - music playback, annotating, wireless connectivity etc.
I went with the Sony instead of the Kindle or one of the others for these reasons:
- The Kindle supports less formats and the main place to get books is Amazon via the wireless (phone) network, which isn’t available outside the US, not even Canada.
- The Sony fully supports PDF’s with a nice feature of re-flowing the text to handle the full A4 size.
- The Sony is cheaper.
- The Sony has some nice 3rd party tools like Calibre and converters like PDF2LRF. I like to tinker with those sort of tools. It also means that it basically supports all formats, either natively or by using a converter.
- The Sony looks more sexy. This might not sound like an important reason but this device is used by way of staring at it for long periods of time :-)
For someone in the US it’s probably worth it to take a closer and harder look at the Kindle. Especially if you’re already getting most of your reading material from Amazon. There are rumors of a next gen device coming “soon” btw.
Lastly, there’s a really good forum for discussing the pros and cons of devices, following industry news and downloading royalty-free ebooks called MobileRead.com. I lurked there for quite a while doing my research before pulling the trigger on the purchase.


